On Nov. 25, 2008, a jury determined that dogs were not to blame for an accident that injured a motorcyclist.
In 2002, Ronald Ashley was riding his motorcycle in Midlothian when he claimed two dogs ran into his path and caused him to fall. He sustained five fractured ribs and a collapsed lung in the incident.
Seeking $50,000 in damages, Ashley sued the dogs’ owners, Cathy and C.L. Smith, alleging they violated the city’s leash law.